Epistemology

Opinion

How does opinion differ from knowledge, and what authority does it deserve?

Ancient Greek
Responds to:
Renaissance/Early Modern
Responds to:
Responds to:
Enlightenment
Responds to:
Responds to:
Responds to:
20th Century
Responds to:
finis

The Reading List

Follow this thread through the primary texts, in the order they enter the conversation.

1. Plato, , Books V–VII; ; — the divided line, right opinion vs. knowledge, and the problem of true belief without justification
2. Aristotle, , Book VI; — opinion of the contingent, practical wisdom, and the role of endoxa
3. Michel de Montaigne, , "Apology for Raymond Sebond" — universal skepticism and the limits of human judgment
4. René Descartes, , Meditations I and IV — methodological doubt, the cogito, and the will's role in error
5. John Locke, , Book IV — the faculties of knowledge and judgment, probability, and the right to opinion
6. David Hume, , Sections I, IV–V — the limits of reason, custom as the guide of life
7. Immanuel Kant, , "The Canon of Pure Reason" — opinion, belief, and knowledge as three modes of assent
8. William James, ; — beliefs as habits of action, truth as what works
9. William James, — the legitimacy of commitment where evidence runs out

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.